Creamy Southern Potato Salad Recipe

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

The Comfort of Creamy Southern Potato Salad Recipe

There’s something deeply comforting about a well-made potato salad that feels like a warm hug on a sunny afternoon. I love how this Creamy Southern Potato Salad Recipe brings together familiar flavors with just the right touch of tang and texture. It’s the kind of dish you’ll want to share at family picnics, backyard barbecues, or lazy weekend dinners.

What I find most charming is how the potatoes stay tender yet hold their shape, wrapped in a velvety, lightly crisp dressing dotted with crunchy celery and sweet onion. You’ll notice how the paprika adds a hint of smoky warmth on the finish that rounds everything out gracefully. This isn’t just any potato salad — it’s a celebration of Southern flavors that feel both nostalgic and fresh.

Whether it’s your first time making it or you’ve been perfecting your own version over the years, this recipe guides you gently through every step to get that signature creamy, satisfying bite.

Ingredient Guide

• Yukon Gold or Russet Potatoes (3 lbs): These starchy varieties create tender bites that won’t fall apart. Yukon Gold offers a buttery, creamy texture; russet keeps its shape wonderfully.
• Full-Fat Mayonnaise (1 cup): The creamy base that binds, giving that classic Southern richness. Swap with Greek yogurt for a lighter option, but expect different texture.
• Classic Yellow Mustard (2 tbsp): Adds mild tang and depth. Dijon can be used for a sharper note but adjust quantity to taste.
• Sweet Pickle Relish (2 tbsp): Brings a delightful sweet-tart contrast. Dill relish works nicely if you prefer more tang.
• Apple Cider Vinegar (2 tbsp): Enhances brightness and balances creaminess.
• Celery (½ cup, finely chopped): For fresh, crisp crunch that lightens the dish.
• Sweet or White Onion (½ cup, minced): Adds a gentle bite without overpowering.
• Hard-Cooked Eggs (4 large, coarsely chopped): Classic Southern touch, creamy with a mild savory flavor.
• Ground Black Pepper & Paprika (½ tsp each): Seasoning highlights subtle heat and smoky warmth; extra paprika for garnish adds inviting color.
• Salt (1½ tsp for boiling): Essential for seasoning potatoes from the start.
• Optional Toppings: Finely sliced green onions or extra chopped pickles for garnish and extra zing.

Prep Before You Begin

Before diving into this Creamy Southern Potato Salad Recipe, get your mise en place ready—it makes the process feel relaxed and easy. Peel and dice your potatoes into 1-inch pieces for even cooking. Have your eggs hard-cooked, chopped, and ready to go. Measure your ingredients beforehand and keep all the veggies finely chopped.

This recipe doesn’t require an oven, but chilling the potato salad after mixing really enhances those flavors, so plan for at least an hour in the fridge. It’s the difference between a good salad and a great one.

How to Make Creamy Southern Potato Salad Recipe

1. Place the diced potatoes into a large saucepan and cover them completely with cold water. Add the measured salt—it’s key to seasoning the potatoes from the start.
2. Bring the water to a boil, then reduce the heat to a gentle simmer. You’ll want to cook the potatoes for about 12 to 15 minutes until they’re just tender but still hold their shape when pierced with a fork. This balance keeps the salad from becoming mushy.
3. Drain the potatoes thoroughly and spread them out slightly to cool. I like to let them rest at room temperature briefly; this keeps the final salad from becoming watery.
4. Whisk together the mayonnaise, yellow mustard, relish, apple cider vinegar, ground paprika, black pepper, and a pinch of salt in a spacious mixing bowl. You want a smooth, velvety dressing that will coat every bite.

5. Gently fold the cooled potatoes, chopped hard-cooked eggs, celery, and minced onion into the dressing. Take your time here—stirring carefully keeps the potatoes mostly whole while ensuring every piece is luxuriously coated.
6. Cover the bowl tightly with plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least one hour. This chilling step allows the flavors to meld and intensify beautifully. I often find it tastes even better the next day.
7. When ready to serve, transfer the salad to a pretty serving dish. Lightly dust with extra paprika for a warm red pop of color. Finish with a sprinkle of green onions or chopped pickles for an extra layer of bite and texture.

Creative Variations for Creamy Southern Potato Salad Recipe

• Smoked Bacon: Crisp crumbles stirred in add smoky richness and extra texture.
• Fresh Herbs: Toss in chopped dill, parsley, or chives for an aromatic freshness.
• Spicy Kick: Add a dash of hot sauce or a pinch of cayenne for gentle heat.
• Sweet Twist: Mix in finely diced apples or grapes for a surprising sweet crunch.
• Pickle Variations: Experiment with bread-and-butter or spicy pickles to change the tang level.
• Veggie Boost: Fold in diced bell peppers or shredded carrots to up the color and nutrition.

Storage, Freezing & Reheating

• Refrigerate: Store covered in the fridge for up to 3 days. Flavors deepen, but best served chilled.
• Freezing: Not recommended, as mayonnaise-based salads separate when frozen.
• Reheating: Enjoy cold or at room temperature. Avoid microwaving to keep texture intact.
• Make Ahead: Prepare a day early and keep chilled; just remember to stir gently before serving.

Creamy Southern Potato Salad Recipe FAQs

• Can I use red potatoes instead? Red potatoes can work but may be waxier and don’t break down as much, changing the texture slightly.
• Why do I need to salt the boiling water? Salting the water seasons the potatoes from inside out, making every bite flavorful.
• How do I know when the potatoes are done? They should be tender enough to pierce with a fork but not so soft that they fall apart during stirring.
• Can I swap the mayo for something else? You can try Greek yogurt or a vegan mayo, but expect a thinner, less creamy result.
• Is it better served cold or room temperature? Both work well, though chilling melds the flavors best. Serve within 1-2 hours after taking out of the fridge.

Print