Butterfinger Martini Recipe

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

The Comfort of Butterfinger Martini Recipe

There’s something undeniably comforting about a cocktail that feels like a sweet little indulgence but doesn’t overwhelm your palate. That’s exactly where the Butterfinger Martini Recipe shines—its golden, velvety notes bring the nostalgia of candy bar magic right into your glass. I love how this drink effortlessly blends those buttery, chocolate, and creamy layers into a cocktail you’ll want to savor by candlelight on any chill evening.

You’ll notice the familiar crunch and richness when you finish your sip, especially if you add that crushed Butterfinger garnish—trust me, it’s a total game-changer. Whether you’re unwinding after a long week or looking to impress a crowd, this cocktail hugs you from the inside out.

Honestly, this recipe feels like a small celebration every time I shake it up. It’s straightforward, cozy, and perfect for sharing stories over. Let’s dive into why this Butterfinger Martini Recipe is such a keeper.

Ingredient Guide

• Butterscotch Schnapps (1 oz): Adds that golden sweetness that mimics caramelized sugar; if you’re out, a rich butterscotch syrup mixed with a splash of vodka works in a pinch.
• Chocolate Liqueur (1 oz): I use crème de cacao for its smooth cocoa elegance, but any chocolate liqueur will deepen the velvet chocolate notes.
• Irish Cream Liqueur (1 oz): Baileys or a similar brand brings a luscious creaminess and subtle whiskey warmth, rounding out the drink perfectly.
• Ice Cubes: Essential for chilling and light dilution, making your cocktail silky smooth.
• Optional Crushed Butterfinger Candy: For garnish that adds nostalgic crunch and extra flair—perfect for presentation and texture play.

Prep Before You Begin

Before you start shaking, set up your mise en place. Having your liqueurs measured and your ice ready makes the process breezy and enjoyable. For this Butterfinger Martini Recipe, there’s no oven or long waiting time, so it suits last-minute crafting beautifully. Chill your cocktail glass in the fridge or freezer to keep that first sip icy cold—this little touch really elevates the experience.

• Cocktail shaker with a tight-fitting lid
• Measuring jigger or small measuring cup
• Metal strainer (or use the shaker’s built-in strainer)
• Rocks or martini glasses—chilled if possible
• Small bowl or plate for crushed Butterfinger garnish (optional)
• Ice cubes (preferably large and fresh for slower dilution)

How to Make Butterfinger Martini Recipe

1. Fill your cocktail shaker about two-thirds full with fresh ice cubes—the bigger and clearer, the better for a clean chill.
2. Pour in 1 oz of butterscotch schnapps, 1 oz of chocolate liqueur, and 1 oz of Irish cream liqueur over the ice. You’ll notice the aromas start to play beautifully together already.
3. Seal the shaker tightly and shake vigorously for about 15 seconds. This chills the mix quickly and creates a delicate, frothy texture that feels luxurious on your tongue.

4. Strain the cocktail into a chilled martini or rocks glass. If you want the full experience, try rimming your glass with crushed Butterfinger candy beforehand by wetting the rim lightly with schnapps.
5. Garnish with a sprinkle of crushed Butterfinger candy on top for a textured, aromatic finish—each bite has this lightly crisp contrast that’s pure joy.
6. Serve immediately and enjoy the layered, indulgent flavors that feel like a velvety hug.

Creative Variations for Butterfinger Martini Recipe

• Espresso twist: Add a shot of cold espresso for a moody, bittersweet balance.
• Holiday cheer: Swap out butterscotch schnapps for peppermint schnapps and dust with crushed candy canes instead of Butterfinger.
• Nutty upgrade: Add a splash of hazelnut liqueur for a toasted, earthy nuance.
• Dairy-free version: Use a coconut cream liqueur or non-dairy Irish cream to keep things smooth and allergy-friendly.
• Frozen delight: Blend all ingredients with ice to make a slushy, indulgent martini perfect for summer.

Storage, Freezing & Reheating

• Best served fresh: The Butterfinger Martini Recipe tastes creamy and luscious right after shaking.
• If you must store, keep in a sealed container in the fridge up to 24 hours—give it a gentle stir before serving.
• Freezing isn’t recommended as the cream liqueur and schnapps separate and texture suffers.
• Reheating cocktails like this isn’t ideal; enjoy chilled or on the rocks for the best experience.

Butterfinger Martini Recipe FAQs

• Can I make this cocktail without alcohol? You can use non-alcoholic butterscotch and chocolate syrups with a splash of cream for a mocktail version, but it won’t have the same kick.
• What glassware works best? Martini glasses provide elegance, but rocks glasses with ice are cozy and casual—both highlight different textures.
• How do I get the crushed Butterfinger candy rind to stick? Lightly moisten the glass rim with some butterscotch schnapps or simple syrup, then dip into the crushed candy for a secure, tasty rim.
• Can I prepare these ahead at a party? Measure and mix the ingredients in a pitcher and keep chilled, then shake with fresh ice when ready to serve for freshness.
• What’s the best way to shake the cocktail? Shake firmly but not aggressively to avoid excess dilution—aim for about 15 seconds with a brisk rhythm to marry flavors and chill perfectly.

Print